Easegill pointed to this video this on Twitter which offers an intriguing twist on the notions of piracy and innovation.

Essentially, the argument is: without a certain amount of piracy, i.e., law breaking, our culture would stagnate--creativity, new ideas, new social and economic opportunities would be less likely to occur. [How edupunk is that?]

Let's face it, the movie industry would not exist without piracy, nor would the United States of America. Following the rules is something we learn early in our developmental years. We need these rules to make sense out of the world. Yet, once we begin to gain consciousness of ourselves and the different rules that shape society and culture, "interesting" things are sure to follow.

One of my favorite stages of human development are the "Why?" years. Parents and teachers learn to address this boundless curiosity with a number of strategies, some of which teach kids to stop questioning and merely accept things as the way they are, regardless of why they are the way they are.

My favorite part of college during my early years was when I had a professor who would re-introduce "Why?" Why do we believe what we believe? Why does language have such an impact on how we see the world? Why are you studying poetry? [That last comment was from my parents.]

When I think of piracy, the metaphor churns up more than movie-friendly swashbucklers. The first thing that comes to mind is the notion of stealing valuable goods and taking control of other people's property. I think the word I'm looking for is "stealing." Piracy in this sense smacks of a rather sordid affair. So it seems it's one thing to break a rule and it's another to steal something which is not rightfully yours. (See this related article regarding a study commissioned by Microsoft "that aims to quantify the economic impact of piracy on related small businesses in the software ecosystem and identifies sales of software licenses to pirates as a key economic opportunity for small vendors.")

Stealing ideas, now here's where things get exceptionally dicey.

The mash-up has been in existence since the beginning of recorded time. People have been combining ideas, lyrics, melodies, and images for centuries, creating truly some of the most important inventions, music, and ideas we as a civilization have ever known. So, given the useful tools for appropriating information, sounds, images, and ideas, when is stealing illegal anymore? Copyright laws were designed to protect both creators and users of information, but who is out there enforcing these laws when the scale of appropriation is simply beyond the scope of control? And what about what we're teaching kids and educators in schools about appropriating content? Are we teaching about "fair use," or other copyright uses and responsibilities? My guess is those ethical and legal considerations are being swept under the rug.

So, is the issue that of stealing or are we operating from a set of rules that can no longer be enforced? I find the question almost as delicious as the possible solutions! 

Image: Howard Pyle -- Walking the Plank.